"Smoke Sellers" in the business world

In the business environment, where innovation and enthusiasm are commonplace, certain figures stand out not for their execution skills but for their ability to sell ideas: the "smoke sellers." These professionals, armed with undeniable eloquence and charisma, have the knack for painting visions of success and progress that excite both executives and employees alike. However, once these projects are implemented at a high cost, they face the harsh reality: a lack of substance and commitment to see them through to completion.

"Smoke sellers" are masters of persuasion. They use language filled with promises, impressive statistics, and optimistic projections that portray an image of imminent success. Their talent for weaving compelling narratives about corporate transformations, disruptive innovations, or unprecedented operational efficiencies enables them to secure the support needed to kick-start major projects. In meetings, conferences, and presentations, their presence is magnetic, turning skepticism into enthusiasm.

However, the magic of words often fades quickly once projects are underway. The implementation phase reveals the true nature of these projects:

Lack of Planning: Often, grand ideas are not accompanied by detailed and viable plans. The absence of a solid strategy for execution leads to projects becoming unmanageable or inefficient.

Resistance to Hard Work: While the "smoke seller" enjoys the spotlight during the conceptualization stage, the reality of project management, with its demands for time, resources, and effort, is less appealing. The necessary commitment to keep a project alive and productive is not among their strengths.

High Costs, Low Results: Projects driven by this rhetoric tend to be costly in terms of financial investment, time, and human resources. When these do not translate into tangible benefits, initial enthusiasm turns into frustration and disillusionment.

The consequences of supporting "smoke sellers" can be significant:

Loss of Trust: Employees and executives can lose faith in leadership when they see that grand announcements do not materialize into results.

Waste of Resources: Both economic and human capital are poorly utilized, diverting resources from more viable projects.

Impact on Corporate Culture: A series of failed projects can lead to a culture of cynicism towards new initiatives, making future genuine innovation efforts more challenging.

Therefore, to avoid falling into the trap of "smoke sellers," companies should:

Promote Transparency: There must be clarity regarding expectations, resources, and risks associated with any project.

Rigorous Evaluation: Implement review processes that go beyond initial enthusiasm, thoroughly assessing technical and economic viability.

Balanced Leadership: Foster leaders who not only sell ideas but also demonstrate the ability to execute them. The combination of vision with pragmatism is key.

Culture of Accountability: Create an environment where accountability is the norm, ensuring that those who propose projects are also responsible for their execution.

"Smoke sellers," so common in all businesses, alert us to the need not to be swayed by words alone and to demand periodic checks to ensure that what is presented and approved does not remain just words but is worked on until completion, with regular accountability.
 

A journey through the history of the pharmaceutical industry and one of its great laboratories that had its origins in Alfred Nobel...

“From Alfred Nobel to AstraZeneca” (Vicente Fisac, Amazon) is available in e-Book and print editions: https://a.co/d/9svRTuI